Facebook, Twitter, and Livejournal
Sep. 1st, 2010 04:35 pmOkay, I understand that a lot of people are upset by the fact that User A can directly connect her comments in User B's LJ to User A's own Facebook account, including linking to the post where the comments were made, even if it's a locked post.
What I'm not understanding is everyone's threats of "If you, flist, do any of this, you are dead to me."
1) While this enhancement implementation is new, the concept has been possible ever since copy/paste was available (ie, since before LJ existed). If I wanted to, I could copy and paste a comment that I made in a friend's LJ and put it as my Facebook status. I could even copy/paste the link to that entry, regardless of it's security-level, and put it on my Facebook. Does that make it right? Of course not. But if you think that this new feature somehow makes your content less protected, you're mistaken - it's already subject to copying and pasting at someone's will. And now that Facebook has the ability to do @Usernames which will show up on that @user's wall, it's even EASIER to connect the two social networking sites.
2) If you are really concerned that some people on your flist may do this, then you need to evaluate who's on your flist. Or at least evaluate what filters they're on. It's easy for people to connect LiveJournal Lizzie9208 to the Elizabeth Hartman on Facebook (after all, my AIM nickname listed on FB is Lizzie9208), so all of my public LJ entries are things I wouldn't mind my mom reading. Most of my flocked entries are things I wouldn't mind my mom reading, either, to be honest. I have other filters based upon who I want reading the content, which is also based upon how much I trust them. If someone abuses that trust, then they're immediately kicked off that filter. But they're also on those filters because I *know* they wouldn't post comments - their own or mine, or my posts - in other places, regardless of whether LJ has a fancy tool that does it or not.
So, y'all, calm down. I don't like this new feature and I hope LJ creates a way to disable it, but please do not think that just because those checkboxes are there means that your LJ is suddenly a lot less secure than it has been in the past. This is just a tool that skips a couple of the steps you would otherwise have to do on your own if you wanted to copy/paste a comment into FB.
What I'm not understanding is everyone's threats of "If you, flist, do any of this, you are dead to me."
1) While this enhancement implementation is new, the concept has been possible ever since copy/paste was available (ie, since before LJ existed). If I wanted to, I could copy and paste a comment that I made in a friend's LJ and put it as my Facebook status. I could even copy/paste the link to that entry, regardless of it's security-level, and put it on my Facebook. Does that make it right? Of course not. But if you think that this new feature somehow makes your content less protected, you're mistaken - it's already subject to copying and pasting at someone's will. And now that Facebook has the ability to do @Usernames which will show up on that @user's wall, it's even EASIER to connect the two social networking sites.
2) If you are really concerned that some people on your flist may do this, then you need to evaluate who's on your flist. Or at least evaluate what filters they're on. It's easy for people to connect LiveJournal Lizzie9208 to the Elizabeth Hartman on Facebook (after all, my AIM nickname listed on FB is Lizzie9208), so all of my public LJ entries are things I wouldn't mind my mom reading. Most of my flocked entries are things I wouldn't mind my mom reading, either, to be honest. I have other filters based upon who I want reading the content, which is also based upon how much I trust them. If someone abuses that trust, then they're immediately kicked off that filter. But they're also on those filters because I *know* they wouldn't post comments - their own or mine, or my posts - in other places, regardless of whether LJ has a fancy tool that does it or not.
So, y'all, calm down. I don't like this new feature and I hope LJ creates a way to disable it, but please do not think that just because those checkboxes are there means that your LJ is suddenly a lot less secure than it has been in the past. This is just a tool that skips a couple of the steps you would otherwise have to do on your own if you wanted to copy/paste a comment into FB.